The Frugal Café | Photo credit: Rebecca Anne, "Flora's Cup"</a> | Creative Commons License,
Photo credit: Rebecca Anne, "Flora's Cup" | Creative Commons License,

Frugal Café Philosophy
Save more.
Spend wisely.
Use resources responsibly.
Laugh often.
Kindle passion in life.
Give back.









Frugal Café Site Search:



Bell Peppers: Colors and Flavor – Is There a Difference? Plus, How to Roast a Bell Pepper

By Vicki McClure Davidson


Do different-colored peppers taste differently from each other? | Photo credit: Dmitry Maslov
Do different-colored peppers taste differently from each other? | Photo credit: Dmitry Maslov

The prices of fresh bell (or sweet) peppers in the produce department of the grocery store vary greatly—green bell peppers usually are cheapest, and red, yellow/gold, and orange are more expensive. There are even more rare colors of bell pepper: purple, pink, blue, rainbow, aqua, violet, maroon, white, black, and brown, depending on when they are harvested and the specific cultivar.

Bell peppers fall into the category of sweet peppers and have no "heat," unlike other peppers, such as Anaheim, Hatch, jalepeño, serrano, pasilla, Scotch bonnet, habañero, bhut jolokia, and others. Bell peppers contain a recessive gene that eliminates capsaicin, the compound responsible for the "hotness" of other peppers. So on a scale of hotness, bell peppers earn a rating of zero.

For the most part, all bell peppers are grown from the same plant; they are members of the species Capsicum annuum. With the more common color varieties, why is there such a price difference when they are from the same family? Why do red, yellow, or gold peppers always cost at least twice (sometimes three times) as much as green?

Simple. Green bell peppers are unripe, and the other color varieties have been left on the plant longer to ripen. The ripening process takes additional time, so growers must tend to them longer. The price jump passes on the additional cost to the consumer to compensate the grower for the extra time needed for the bell pepper to ripen.

If you're paying more for a red pepper than for a green, is it worth it? Is there a difference in flavor that would justify the additional cost? Important detail for the frugal cook to know.

We turned to one of our favorite sources to find the answer. America's Test Kitchen conducted a study on this very thing back in 2001.

From America's Test Kitchen:

"We conducted a blind tasting to find out if those cheerfully colored bell peppers taste as different from one another as they look or have simply been cultivated for eye appeal. Wearing blindfolds, our editorial staff tasted both raw and blanched samples of red, yellow, orange, green, and purple peppers fresh from the market.

"No one guessed all of the colors correctly, but the differences in taste were dramatic. The favorite colors turned out to be red and orange; without exhibiting much of a pungent pepper flavor, both were pleasantly sweet. The yellow pepper, with its mildly sweet and slightly tannic flavor, was also well liked. The green pepper, the most easily recognized, was universally disliked for its unripe bitterness. The absolute worst entry, however, was the thin-skinned purple pepper. Its slimy texture and singularly unpleasant flavor elicited comments such as, "Did I just eat a slug?"

"As it turned out, these comments weren't far off the mark. As a bell pepper ripens, it turns from green to yellow, orange, or red, depending on the variety. These bright peppers are sweeter simply because they are ripe, whereas the bitter green pepper is unripe. Purple peppers, too, are harvested when immature and would turn an uncommonly dark green if allowed to ripen fully. So unless you're fond of the tannic bitterness of the common green and the purple varieties, we suggest sticking with yellow, orange, or red."

So, there is indeed a difference in flavor. Which color of pepper you choose will depend on your personal taste preference and how the bell pepper will be served.

Roasting any pepper will increase its sweetness and flavor. It doesn't take too much time to roast peppers, and the payoff in additional flavor is worth the extra effort.

To roast or grill a bell pepper (or any sweet or hot pepper):

Once the peppers have blackened and softened, transfer the blackened peppers to a paper or plastic bag and seal them up, or wrap them in aluminum foil. If you roasted or grilled the peppers whole, cut them in half now and scrape out the stems, seeds, and whitish membrane. For hotter peppers, use a paring knife or cover your hands with plastic bags or wear food prep gloves to remove the seeds and membrane. You don't want to have your hands come into contact with the seeds and membrane of a hot pepper, like a jalepeño, as the chemicals they contain can be horribly harsh on hands. Accidentally touching your eyes with any particle of capsaicin from a hot chile pepper left on your fingertips will be excruciatingly painful. Throw away the gloves or plastic bags when you're done. You don't need to be cautious working with bell peppers, as they contain no heat.

Let the peppers set undisturbed for at least 15 minutes to steam. Once the peppers have steamed and then cooled, the skins can be easily peeled away. You can peel them using either your fingers, a vegetable peeler, or a paring knife. The skins should peel off easily. Don't run cold water over the pepper, as this will leech out flavor. Leave on some of the blackened char on the pepper, as it is tasty and adds to the smoky flavor. Discard the skins, remove and discard the veins and seeds if you want a milder flavor.

At this point, you can proceed with your recipe or dice and freeze the peppers for future use. Freezing them will decrease their crunchiness, so they will be a bit limp if served raw, but used in any cooked dishes will be just fine. You can use roasted bell peppers in a variety of dishes, such as dips, soups, casseroles, hors d'ouevres, pizzas, and pasta sauces. They boost the flavor of ho-hum sandwiches.

For a simple, great-tasting appetizer or snack, just add sliced roasted peppers and place them on top of Italian bread slices and top with a bit of olive oil, basil, and grated Parmesan cheese.

Roasting and freezing your own diced bell peppers is a huge money saver, especially when you look at the high price of a small bag of frozen diced bell peppers in your grocer's freezer. Take advantage of sales of bell peppers and then roast and freeze them for later when the prices have climbed up during the off-season.

Nutritionally, all peppers, sweet or hot, contain good levels of beta-carotene (related to vitamin A) and vitamin C. Peppers that have been allowed to mature from green to red have twice as much vitamin C as when they were green. Red sweet bell peppers have 11 times the beta carotene of green bell peppers. One serving of bell pepper has about 17 calories, so slices of bell pepper are great for a flavorful, nutritious, non-fattening snack.



Related Reading & Recipes:
Frugal Café Blog Zone: Fab Food Friday Fotos: The Explosive Fourth of July "Salads, Salads, & More Salads" Food & Recipe Extravaganza
Frugal Café Blog Zone: Fab Food Friday Fotos & Recipes: Ponzu Noodle Salad Bowl, Banana Cheesecake, Cheese & Ham Tart, Peruvian Garlic-Lime Chicken, Spinach Lemon Pesto, Pork Chop Stuffing Bake, Okra, Chicken & Eggplant Gumbo, Thrifty Recipes
Frugal Café Blog Zone: Fab Food Friday Fotos & Recipes: Taco Salad, Chinese Cabbage Rolls, Beet-Lemon Cupcakes, Amish Chicken Pot Pie, Peach & Blueberry Rustic Tart, Squash & Turkey Casserole, Buttermilk Bacon Ranch Mac & Cheese, Tres Leche, Vietnamese Beef Jerky, More Cheap Recipes
Frugal Café Blog Zone: Celebration of Awesome Autumn & Oktoberfest Food Edition, with Frugal Recipes
Frugal Café's Savvy 16 Redux: 16 More Kitchen & Shopping Tricks to Save You Money & Time: Chopping Jalepeños, Whipped Frosting, Garlic Mincing, Gravy Messes, Eggs, Zucchini, & More
The Beautiful Burrito: Make Your Own and Save Money
Frugal Kitchen Tips: More Bang for Your Buck... Keep Your Spices and Dried Herbs Fresh Longer
Frugal Café Blog Zone: Farmers' Markets & Local Veggies: Buying, Selling, & Adding Personal Touches Could Help Farmers' Sales
Winging It: Three Hot Wings Sauce Recipes: Supreme Hot Wings, Hooters' Copy-Cat Hot Wings, & Honey Hot Wings
Celebrity Recipes: Emeril Lagasse's Homemade Pepper Sauce
Celebrity Recipes: Martina McBride's Tortilla Soup
Celebrity Recipes: Trisha Yearwood's Chicken Pizza
Celebrity Recipes: Loretta Lynn's Crispy Fried Chicken
Celebrity Recipes: Bob Barker's Mexican Chili Con Queso
The Truth about Tomatoes
Frugal Café Blog Zone: Fab Food Friday Fotos and Recipes: BBQ Cabbage, Ham & Cheese Omelette, Banana Bento, Lentil-Nut Loaf, Pistachio Almond Cupcakes, Meatballs Toscana, Pasta, Chicken Fried Bacon, Potato-Herb Bread, Turkey Chili, African Kale & Yam Soup, Recipes, & More
Frugal Café Blog Zone: Fab Food Friday Fotos and RecipesSweet & Sour Chicken, Chickpeas & Baby Spinach, Frosted Donuts, Orzo Salad, Fishball Soup, A Perfect Red Apple, Sausage Skillet, Frugal Recipes, & More
Fore! 9 Golf-Inspired Easy, Frugal Main Dish Recipes for People Who Don't Have Much Time to Spend in the Kitchen
Frugal Café Economical Foods Info & Checklist
Traditional and Unique: Six Different Holiday Green Bean Casserole Recipes
Frugal Café Blog Zone: Wow, That’s A Lot of Leftover Turkey… Frugal Café with Easy, Cheap Recipes for Turkey Leftovers
Rochester Sweet and Sour Lentils
Hearty and Cheap: Old-Fashioned Beef Stew Recipe
How to Properly Prep Puzzling Veggies
Blanching Times for Vegetables
Celebrity Recipes: Giada De Laurentiis's Homemade Italian Sauce
Frugal Café Blog Zone: The Pantry Principle and Other Prudent Ways to Stock Up and Save Money on Food
Frugal Café Blog Zone: Food Jungle Conquest: Diced Chile Peppers, Bargain Bin
Cuttin' It Up in the Kitchen: Food Poisoning and Cutting Boards
Descoware: Vintage Cookware Still Popular... and a Bargain to Boot


America's Test Kitchen, (, March 1, 2001.
How Stuff Works, Bell Peppers (
WH Foods, "Bell pepper," (
Wikipedia, "Bell Pepper," (